I was lucky enough to get a shirt.

I don't remember what it cost and honestly if it cost me $5 more than last year's shirt it was well worth it.
I don't buy shirts to put in drawers or clean my cars with. If I like the design I will wear it.

That being said a reprint of this shirt should be made available to members who want them.
Somewhere in this thread there was concern about the cost of a smaller run.
The shirts you made were silkscreened, so you have screens involved.

Technology is constantly changing, the shirts can be digitally printed with a direct to garment process, no set up charges, no screen charges, all you need is a min of 12.

Next Year, you should pre sell the shirts and let the members pick them up at the promo table.
Again, due to digital printing you can print full color on a dark colored shirt.